Check out the Pro's and Cons when deciding
When it comes to health insurance, employees and employers in the UK often wonder whether a company health scheme or a personal health scheme is the better option. Both have their perks and downsides. Let’s break them down to help you decide which one might be right for you.
Company Health Schemes
Pros:
Cost Sharing: With a company health scheme, employees only pay the P11D benefit. This means lower out-of-pocket costs compared to paying full premiums for a personal health scheme.
Risk Distribution: In a group scheme, high claims costs are spread across all participants. This helps keep premiums stable and predictable.
Comprehensive Coverage: Group schemes often offer better terms and more benefits because they leverage the collective bargaining power of the entire group.
Administrative Ease: Managing one group policy is much simpler and more cost-effective than dealing with multiple individual policies.
Employee Satisfaction: Offering a group health scheme can make a company more attractive to current and potential employees, aiding in retention and overall job satisfaction.
Cons:
Less Personalised: The coverage is designed for the group, which might not fit every individual's needs perfectly.
P11D Tax Liability: Employees may face some tax implications due to the P11D benefit, although this is usually less than the cost of personal premiums.
Tied to Employment: If you leave the company, you might lose your coverage.
Personal Health Schemes
Pros:
Customised Coverage: Personal health schemes can be tailored to fit your specific health needs and preferences.
Portability: Your coverage stays with you regardless of job changes, offering continuity.
Policy Control: You have full control over your policy choices, including the level of coverage and the insurer.
Cons:
Higher Costs: You pay the full premium, which can be significantly higher than the P11D benefit cost in a company scheme.
No Risk Sharing: Without a group to share the risk, your premiums can increase substantially if you make claims.
Administrative Burden: You are responsible for managing and maintaining your policy, which can be time-consuming.
Deciding between a company health scheme and a personal health scheme depends on what matters most to you. Company health schemes are generally more cost-effective and offer comprehensive coverage due to shared risk and group bargaining power. On the other hand, personal health schemes provide customisation and portability, making them ideal if you need specific coverage or change jobs frequently.
If you’re interested in personal health plans, we can help with that too, but please note these will not be counted as an employee benefit.
For more detailed advice, consider consulting with a financial advisor to understand all the implications and ensure compliance with UK Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) regulations.
Comments